//

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest news and events from TWI:

Subscribe >
Skip to content

Technical Insight: Hydrogen Testing

As world leaders in the field of hydrogen embrittlement, TWI has conducted a range of experiments over the years to better understand the impact of hydrogen on the properties of different materials as well as developing techniques to avoid hydrogen embrittlement.

TWI’s solutions can be tailored to meet the specific requirements of our Members, from modelling hydrogen permeation through different materials and component geometries, selecting materials or coatings to minimise hydrogen ingress, to offering specialised hydrogen testing services to evaluate component integrity.

We have over 60 years of experience in helping industry cope with the effects of hydrogen, including techniques to mitigate fabrication hydrogen embrittlement during manufacture, such as might occur during coating or welding processes. We also have experts that are able to assess the resistance of materials to hydrogen environment embrittlement, such as when a part is exposed to a hydrogen-charging environment in service. This includes evaluation of material performance in high pressure gaseous hydrogen or in electrolytic hydrogen charging environments, such as seawater with cathodic protection.

TWI has conducted a range of projects related to hydrogen testing over the years, some of which are detailed below.

Core Research Programme (CRP)

The core research programme (CRP) involves the creation of projects to address challenges faced by our Industrial Members, advancing technologies and processes and finding new solutions for industry problems. These projects are jointly funded by our Industrial Members, with the outcomes made available to all of our Members.

- The Hydrogen Economy: Materials and Joining Technology Needs

This 2007 CRP report investigates the drivers and barriers to moving away from carbon-based fuels towards the use of hydrogen as a primary energy carrier for solar, wind, wave and tidal energy sources. This work considered general, materials and joining technology gaps that need addressing before a hydrogen economy is viable.

- Real-time Hydrogen Monitoring during Welding

By the time of this 2010 project, it was understood that it would be beneficial to know if there had been a problem with hydrogen control during the welding of thick section steel. Being able to detect and take action against the introduction of hydrogen into the weld could prevent hydrogen cracking and the related cost and time taken for later repair. TWI had already proven the concept of using a hydrogen effusion rate monitoring probe to measure the hydrogen effusion at various stages of welding of procedure qualification pieces to establish baseline levels of hydrogen effusion rate. An understanding of the hydrogen effusion rate via procedure qualification allows remedial action to be taken. This project extended this understanding via additional work carried out to demonstrate the effects of hydrogen effusion on the remaining hydrogen content in the weld and the prevention of cracking in a weld that has experienced a deviation to the intended welding procedure.

- Effect of Hydrogen Gas on Fatigue Performance of Steels

As hydrogen and hydrogen-based fuels attracted increased interest as part of the drive towards a low carbon economy, TWI delivered research to help understand the effects of hydrogen on mechanical properties in all applications, from production, transportation, storage and fuel cells. Building upon past research into hydrogen related embrittlement, this work aimed to investigate the effect of a gaseous hydrogen environment on fatigue properties of steels. This allowed us to identify the major factors promoting hydrogen effects and provide industry with recommendations for mitigation, testing and design in hydrogen environments.

- Mechanical Behaviour of Steels in High Pressure Hydrogen

By 2018, interest in the hydrogen economy had uncovered a need to understand how to safely produce, store and transport hydrogen. Austenitic stainless steels had already shown a lower susceptibility to hydrogen embrittlement than ferritic steels, so TWI undertook a series of mechanical property tests using our unique capabilities for tensile, fracture, crack propagation and fatigue tests in hydrogen at high pressure and high temperature. This allowed us to assess the performance of AISI grades 304, 304L, 321, 347 and 316L in hydrogen gas, producing findings for parameters such as tensile stress, ductility, proof strength, and more (Figure 1).

Joint Industry Projects

Our joint industry projects (JIPs) allow interested parties to come together as project sponsors, pooling resources for greater research outcomes, while also being given exclusive access to the results and the opportunity to guide the direction of the projects themselves.

These projects typically focus on challenges faced by specific industry sectors, providing industry-relevant information, guidance and solutions.

- Testing in High Pressure, High Temperature Hydrogen - Feasibility of Test Rig

This JIP assessed the feasibility of creating a bespoke facility for mechanical testing in high pressure, high temperature (HPHT) hydrogen. The feasibility study focused on identifying the relevant components of the HPHT hydrogen testing system as well as proposing conceptual designs for the general vessel layout and its supporting experimental apparatus

- Material Assessment in Methane-Hydrogen Combinations

Announced in 2023, this JIP addressed the challenge of repurposing existing composite and multi-material pipe infrastructure for use with hydrogen gas, avoiding the need for investment and disruption through new installation. In order to support the continued use of pipelines that had carried natural gas, it is important to understand how the materials may have altered over time. This project summarised the potential chemical and physical alteration in a range of materials when exposed to hydrogen, as well as tracking critical material properties. We also compared selected permeation rates of methane and methane-hydrogen blends with inter-dispersed rapid gas decompression events.

Public Funded Projects

Our expert teams are also called to participate in public funded projects in partnership with other organisations from industry and academia to solve specific challenges, typically for particular industry sectors.

- Monitoring Systems for Safe Usage of Hydrogen Power

Funded by the European Commission, the two-year ‘SafeHPower’ project saw TWI join a consortium to develop a condition monitoring technique to improve the safety of hydrogen fuel storage tanks. Two prototype monitoring systems were created based upon acoustic emission (AE) technology. Designed to continuously monitor tanks throughout the entirety of the storage, distribution and usage phases in the hydrogen transport economy, the prototypes ensure that all defects that could cause eventual leaks are detected in time to avoid catastrophic failures. One of the prototypes was designed for use with vehicles while the other was developed for use with storage tanks.

The vehicle prototype comprised an AE sensor, control box and embedded software, with the system designed and developed with several features to enhance its suitability for installation in a vehicle. Laboratory field trials were conducted to test the prototype in conditions representative of real-world operation in terms of temperature and exposure to water, dust particles, humidity and vibrations (Figures 2-4). An AE array system was designed to continuously monitor large storage steel tanks and, crucially, locate the position of any defects with high accuracy. It comprised an array of sensors (three or more), a PXI platform to provide a basis for building electronic test equipment, automation systems and modular instruments, and advanced signal processing software. This system is capable of providing an early warning of fatigue cracks and hydrogen damage before a defect becomes critical. Laboratory validation trials in which water (rather than hydrogen) at a pressure of 220 bar was stored in a tank containing a flaw showed that the developed AE array system is capable of detecting AE events generated by crack growth (50x2x1mm3 and 50x0.5x5mm3). The triangulation method used by the software successfully located the flaw. In addition, field trials were conducted by installing an array of six sensors, for one month, on a large stationary steel tank with a capacity of 50m3. The results obtained from these tests were comparable to the laboratory results obtained on a sample with flaws (Figures 5-6).

Dedicated Industrial Member Support and Other Projects

Much of the work undertaken at TWI is conducted confidentially on behalf of individual Industrial Member companies. However, there are some examples of these types of project work that involved hydrogen testing that we are able to share with you, as follows…

- Steel and Embrittlement Tests for Hydrogen Transport

TWI was contacted by Industrial Member, Carten Controls to assist with qualifying materials performance in high pressure pure hydrogen through a series of fracture mechanics tests in accordance with ISO 11114 Part 4. This standard was developed in response to the catastrophic failure of cylinders containing hydrogen gas or hydrogen enriched gases, due to the embrittlement of the containment steels. It also provides a method to approve newer steels, with higher tensile strength but reduced impurities, such as sulphur and phosphorous, to be demonstrated for their suitability for hydrogen storage service, alongside more conventional lower grade steels. Test Method B in the standard is a fracture mechanics test (Method A is a disc test), and the test method involves incrementally loading a 26mm wide pre-cracked compact tension specimen in steps, with a twenty minute hold duration at each step to determine whether any crack propagation can be detected from the direct current potential drop (DCPD) monitoring on the specimen. The tests are done at room temperature within a high pressure gas environment containing the relevant embrittling gas, in this case high purity hydrogen. The largest applied load (in terms of stress intensity factor, K, for the specimen) before crack extension occurs is defined at the threshold value, KIH, for the specimen. If two repeat specimens confirm values of KIH above the target value (equal to 60/950 multiplied by the UTS) then the material is qualified to ISO 11114-4 Method B.

To conduct this work, TWI adapted its existing high-pressure hydrogen testing facility so that the tests could be performed routinely, by developing automated control software to carry out the incremental load increase and hold durations while monitoring the DCPD signal throughout the test. The test method that was developed and then proven through work carried out allowed material to be successfully qualified to the ISO 11114-4 standard on behalf of Carten Controls (Figures 7-9).

These are just some examples of the hydrogen testing work conducted at TWI over the decades, you can find out more about our hydrogen testing services, here:

https://www.twi-global.com/what-we-do/research-and-technology/technologies/laboratories/hydrogen-laboratory

Figure 1. Brittle fracture in low-nickel 304L austenitic steel tested in 400 bar hydrogen at –50°C
Figure 1. Brittle fracture in low-nickel 304L austenitic steel tested in 400 bar hydrogen at –50°C
Figure 2. AE sensor system installed under the vehicle
Figure 2. AE sensor system installed under the vehicle
Figure 3. Typical AE signal detected using the miniature AE sensor system
Figure 3. Typical AE signal detected using the miniature AE sensor system
Figure 4. AE events from a healthy vehicle tank (red circles show the periods of refuelling marked by sharp increase in the AE events)
Figure 4. AE events from a healthy vehicle tank (red circles show the periods of refuelling marked by sharp increase in the AE events)
Figure 5. One of six AE sensors placed on a large H2 storage tank
Figure 5. One of six AE sensors placed on a large H2 storage tank
Figure 6. Bespoke defect localisation map showing the location of the six sensors (blue) along with the estimated defect locations (red)
Figure 6. Bespoke defect localisation map showing the location of the six sensors (blue) along with the estimated defect locations (red)
Figure 7. CT specimen for testing to ISO 11114-4 Method B
Figure 7. CT specimen for testing to ISO 11114-4 Method B
Figure 8. Lowering the pressure vessel down over the CT specimen, loaded and instrumented for testing
Figure 8. Lowering the pressure vessel down over the CT specimen, loaded and instrumented for testing
Figure 9. The incremental load test being carried out inside high pressure hydrogen inside the test vessel
Figure 9. The incremental load test being carried out inside high pressure hydrogen inside the test vessel
}