//

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest news and events from TWI:

Subscribe >
Skip to content

Technical Insight: Additive Manufacturing

Working across industry, TWI has been actively involved in additive manufacturing (AM) innovation for years, as well as helping our Industrial Members with everything from simple feasibility and fabrication projects to full adoption and integration of AM systems. Our experience and expertise has also allowed us to be at the forefront of creating guidance and providing input to codes and standards related to all aspects of AM use for a range of materials; covering everything from manufacture to coating and repair.

Research

Our research has included core research projects that seek to solve the needs of wider industry, joint industry projects that allow sponsors to come together and fund research for their mutual benefit, and dedicated research projects created to solve the challenges of specific Industrial Member companies. In addition, we have participated in many collaborative AM projects. Between them, these projects cover all technology readiness levels and industries, giving us a unique perspective on AM that has led us to deliver landmark innovations that are used across industry today.

- Additive Manufacture of Blisk and Guide Vanes by Friction Welding

A 2012 core research project investigated the use of friction welding techniques as an additive manufacturing approach to build up near net shape parts for the aerospace industry. The project, ‘Additive Manufacture of Blisk and Guide Vanes by Friction Welding’ is an example of how we combine different areas of expertise to find innovative new solutions.

In this instance, we trialled the successive welding of relatively small/simple shapes to each other, and/or to a base component to identify and demonstrate possible applications for friction additive manufacture for a number of industry sectors.

Tests and samples were created from a range of high performance alloys, in order to showcase the potential for manufacture using techniques including rotary friction welding (RFW), linear friction welding (LFW), and friction stir welding (FSW).

The project sought to address the issues around the purchase prices and machining costs of high performance materials by decreasing the volume of raw materials needed, while also reducing the overall production timescales and limiting the amount of energy consumed. This assisted with reducing costs related to materials including titanium, nickel alloys, high strength aluminium and high performance steels, as well as helping circumvent restrictive delivery times, particularly for thick section forms and/or large volume requirements.

Demonstration parts were created and a review was written detailing the status of additive manufacture by friction welding, as applied to high value added components, including consideration of the range of possible materials and friction welding processes.

- Manufacturing Process for Customised Medical Implants

In September 2013, TWI joined a European Commission-funded collaborative project called ‘ImplantDirect,’ which aimed to use additive manufacturing processes to manufacture personalised medical implants. Not only would this reduce the time and cost associated with implant design and manufacture but would benefit patients by reducing pain and tissue damage, time spent in surgery and recovery times.

Selective laser melting (SLM) was the chosen process for the work to produce pre-production prototype system, validated by pre-clinical trials. SLM was chosen in order to reduce both build time and post-processing, while retaining the required levels of accuracy and quality. CT scanning was also used to determine and optimise designs for both the implant and fixings.

The SLM process uses a 3D CAD model of the part, which is sliced into layers that can then be calculated into laser scan paths to define factors including the part boundary, contouring and fill sequence. Powder is then deposited, layer-by-layer, with the surface being melted with a laser beam. A wiper is then used to spread the powder before a high power-density fibre laser with a 20µm beam spot size fully melts the pre-deposited powder layer. The melted particles fuse and solidify to form each layer of the component.

It is estimated that around 500,000 people are admitted to hospitals across Europe each year after having suffered bone, joint, maxillofacial trauma or degenerative diseases that require surgical attention using a customised implant. Added to this are the approximately 2.4 million people who are injured or disabled each year by road traffic accidents in Europe. Meaning that this work had the potential to benefit millions of people each year by reducing the lead times for patient-specific implants from 4-6 weeks to just 7 days.

This project saw us use our technical excellence to transfer a technology to a new sector to produce genuine benefits for the public, while also showing our capability to work to the necessarily exacting standards required by the medical profession.

- Certification of Laser Powder Additive Manufactured Components for Industrial Adoption in the Energy and Offshore Sectors

By 2015 there had been rapid progress in the field of AM as a process to create parts without the use of machining, moulding or casting. Having already shown significant potential for AM to reduce costs in both the aerospace and medical industries, while also demonstrating improved design freedom, weight reduction and lower tooling costs, complemented by reductions in carbon footprint and waste during manufacture, there was a need to create industry product certification guidelines to allow an increased adoption of the process by industry.

Working alongside Lloyd’s Register, we combined research and development efforts with real-world additive manufacturing practices to create new industry product certification guidelines - paving the way for more widespread adoption of the additive manufacturing technology and assisting industry in how best to tap in to its potential.

This project had a particular focus on the energy and offshore sectors, where it sought to identify potential applications for AM before undertaking practical work to determine optimum build parameters and produce components that could then be tested and certified to create the required industry guidelines.

Selective laser melting (SLM) and laser metal deposition (LMD) were the chosen processes to be used for this work, which was delivered as a joint industry project that provided the findings directly to the project sponsors, allowing interested energy and offshore industry operators the opportunity to benefit from the research.

- Validation of Process Models for Additive Manufacturing

Selective laser melting (SLM) was the subject of another project in 2017, where we worked with the SIMULIA brand of Dassault Systèmes to validate the use of finite element modelling (FEM) techniques to accurately simulate additive AM processes. The aim of this AM validation project was to allow for improved part design and process setup before any physical manufacturing takes place. The project results would reduce manufacturing defects in parts and support the development of AM technologies.

We used a Renishaw AM250 machine to produce double cantilever parts from Ti-6Al-4V Grade 23 metal powder with a particle size range of between 15 and 45μm (see figure 2). A 90° alternating scan strategy was used, comprising a series of parallel hatch lines and four boundary contours, which was rotated by 90° after every layer. Electrical discharge machining was used to cut away the support structures below the solid beam surfaces. Upon cutting, the presence of residual stresses generated deflections of the remaining double-sided cantilever beam structure. The out-of-plane deflections were measured using a FaroArm precision measuring tool.

The AM simulations used physics-based FEM formulations to input exact machine information about the powder recoating sequence, laser scan path, and process parameters into the FE model (see figure 3). These models enabled progressive element activation and heating computations, as well as solid surface cooling data during build progression. The simulation model employed temperature-dependent material properties for the heat transfer and stress analysis simulations.

The final validation was achieved through a technical comparison of the physical SLM-manufactured test pieces and the FEM predictions (see figure 4), which showed that there was a strong correlation between the predictions and the test measurements, providing confidence in the modelling approach.

This work helped progress AM processes through the validation of the use of simulations for AM part production.

- D.E.E.P. Project

Having used our expertise to help promote and enable the use of AM in industries including automotive, medical, energy, offshore and aerospace, we are now part of a new collaborative project that will see AM processes investigated for the highly regulated and complex maritime sector.

The Digitally Enabled Efficient Propeller (D.E.E.P.) project has been created to assess a range of advanced AM processes, integrated with digital twin simulation technology, for the creation of a new generation of smart, cyber-physical, marine propellers that are able to monitor their own performance across their operational life.

TWI has joined a consortium of world-leading experts in their respective fields to investigate the technology readiness of different AM processes for the highly-regulated and operationally-complex maritime sector. This work includes benchmarking performance against conventional manufacturing methods with the aim of establishing a pathway to classification approval and type certification. This approach will ensure that the project not only delivers technical innovation, but also creates a credible framework for industrial adoption and regulatory compliance.

With the project now underway, the consortium will begin by evaluating AM processes before creating, testing, and validating a demonstrator propeller on Newcastle University’s research vessel, with the long-term aim of enabling type approval and scaling production for commercial adoption by the global fleet.

Figure 1: A prototype medical implant created using SLM during the ImplantDirect project
Figure 1: A prototype medical implant created using SLM during the ImplantDirect project
Figure 2: SLM double cantilevers (after wire cutting)
Figure 2: SLM double cantilevers (after wire cutting)
Figure 3: Image of residual stress (after wire cutting)
Figure 3: Image of residual stress (after wire cutting)
Figure 4: Comparison between test specimen measurements and finite element predictions of deflection
Figure 4: Comparison between test specimen measurements and finite element predictions of deflection
Figure 5: D.E.E.P. project launch
Figure 5: D.E.E.P. project launch

These projects are just some examples of our experience, expertise, and technical excellence in additive manufacturing and how we continue to advance AM for the wider benefit of industry. You can find out more about additive manufacturing at TWI here, or email contactus@twi.co.uk to see how we can help with your AM challenges.

}