Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest news and events from TWI:

Subscribe >
Skip to content

Preventing and Correcting Weld Material Distortion

Distortion as a result of welding is a concern for industry as it can lead to failure in assets or components.

The material properties of aluminium make it particularly susceptible to distortion, which is a concern for industries such as automotive and aerospace where aluminium is frequently used.

Aluminium alloys, for example, have a higher thermal expansion coefficient than metals such as stainless steel, carbon steel and titanium alloy. In some cases, this coefficient is over twice that of other materials. Other material properties that impact distortion include the working heat, thermal conductivity and differences in weld/parent metal yield strengths and elastic modulus.

Inherent stresses, such as from cold working processes, thermal cutting or prior heat treatment also affects the likelihood of distortion.

What is Distortion?

Distortion can occur as a result of the joining process when a weld pool is formed and the heat affected zone (HAZ) expands. However, as the HAZ cools it contracts, causing tensile stresses in the parent material which may lead to local plastic deformation around the HAZ . This distortion can take different forms depending on the type of weld, including longitudinal and transverse shrinkage, angular shrinkage, twisting, and bowing.

Preventing Distortion

There are three main ways to prevent and control distortion – prevention by design, modelling and prediction, and more advanced methods such as low-stress no distortion welding (LSND).

Prevention by design includes joint design and preparation, welding procedure selection, welding sequence selection, the use of jigs, clamps and strongbacks, and material selection. Weld position can also help prevent distortion by using intermittent welding or welding along a neutral axis. This requires pre-setting and fitting-up, with the required angles determined by experiment or experience. When selecting a welding procedure, it is worth noting that concentrated heat sources, such as with TIG welding, produce less distortion, while fewer passes and a shorter welding time also reduce cumulative shrinkage effects. With regard to clamping, the use of flexible clamps can help maintain the root gap and back-to-back clamping balances shrinkage forces in mirror image fabrications. Bolted or tongue and groove clamps are particularly suited to thin sheet metal welding, making them useful for aluminium welding. Pre-bending can also be used to counteract shrinkage during welding.

Modelling and prediction involves weld sequence optimisation, distortion prediction and thermal-mechanical modelling. Modelling and prediction uses thermal-mechanical models to account for transient temperature profiles, using temperatures to drive thermal expansion and reaction against constraints and calculating the accumulated distortion and residual stress. This allows for the prediction of distortion, the effects of post-weld heat treatments and the optimal weld sequence.

Low-Stress No Distortion welding is usually applied to thin materials and uses a variety of methods. One technique is to cool immediately after deposition, while another method involves heating and cooling different zones. Thermal tensioning and mechanical restraint can also be incorporated into LSND.

 

Correcting Distortion

Distortion in materials can also be corrected after welding, through mechanical measures such as pressing and sizing fixtures or through the use of localised heating for thermal straightening.

The use of pressure can correct bowing but usually requires a degree of trial and error. Other methods of correction include using cones and segments to expand a component from inside and the placing of a heated component on the fixture, which corrects distortion as it cools. Shrinkage can also help correct distortion by pulling the component in contact with segments and stretching out distorted areas.

Thermal straightening can be applied through local heating to correct distortion or spot heating on thin sheet structures.

Codes and Standards

There are several codes and standards that can help prevent distortion, including ABS rules, ASME, DNV GL and BS EN ISO, to name a few. The codes and standards include general guidance as well as more specific industry or application-related rules.

 

TWI has a great deal of knowledge and experience in preventing distortion across industry and with different materials and you can contact us, below, for more information.  

}